LEARNING GUIDE TO:
ROMEO AND JULIET
One of the Best! This movie is on TWM's list of the ten best movies to supplement classes in Drama, High School Level.
For a great introduction to Romeo and Juliet, see TWM's Snippet Lesson Plan for "Shakespeare in Love": An Introduction to Romeo and Juliet.
SUBJECTS — Drama/England;
1968 Franco Zeffirelli Version: Age: 12+: Rated PG; Drama; 138 minutes; Color. Available from Amazon.com.
1996 Baz Luhrmann's "Romeo + Juliet:" Age: 14+: Rated PG-13 for scenes of contemporary violence and some sensuality; Drama; 120 minutes; Color.Available from Amazon.com.
Description: "Romeo and Juliet" is probably the greatest romantic tragedy ever written. It still has relevance today. Many students (and TWM) prefer the Zeffirelli version but many teachers report that students love Baz Luhrmann's "Romeo + Juliet". For a critique of the Luhrmann version, see Robert Ebert's Review of this movie. It's great to have kids watch them both and compare. Perhaps one could be watched in class and the other after school. This is an excellent extra credit project.
Benefits of the Movie: "Romeo and Juliet" is an excellent introduction to Shakespeare. The story allows children to work through the issue of tragic romantic relationships. This film also displays the great weakness of suicide, the risks of holding grudges, the danger of fighting, and the often unintended consequences of revenge.
1968 Franco Zeffirelli Version: MINOR. Shakespeare uses some ribald language, e.g., references to maids lying on their backs etc. There is a little nudity. As Romeo and Juliet awaken after they have spent the night together there is a full view, from the back only, of the body of the actor playing Romeo. The breasts of the actress playing Juliet are shown, very briefly, as she turns to get out of bed.
1996 Baz Luhrmann's "Romeo + Juliet": This has a moderate amount of violence. Some of the dialogue is unintelligible.
Parenting Points: Ask and help your child to answer the Quick Discussion Question and any Social-Emotional Learning Discussion Questions that might interest him or her. Read the play or favorite scenes from the play as a family, see the Bridges to Reading section.
WORKSHEETS: TWM offers the following worksheets to keep students' minds on the movie and direct them to the lessons that can be learned from the film.
Worksheet for Cinematic and Theatrical Elements and Their Effects.
Additional ideas for lesson plans for this movie can be found at TWM's guide to Lesson Plans Using Film Adaptations of Novels, Short Stories or Plays.
Selected Awards, Cast and Director:
1968 Franco Zeffirelli Version:
Selected Awards: 1968 Academy Awards: Best Cinematography, Best Costume Design; 1969 Golden Globe Awards: Best Foreign Film; Most Promising Newcomer - Female (Hussey); Most Promising Newcomer Male (Whiting);
1968 National Board of Review Awards: Ten Best Films of the Year, Best Director (Zeffirelli); 1968 Academy Award Nominations: Best Picture; Best Director (Zeffirelli).
Featured Actors: Olivia Hussey, Leonard Whiting, Michael York, Milo O'Shea.
Director: Franco Zeffirelli.
1996 Luhrmann's "Romeo + Juliet"
Selected Awards: 1997 Academy Awards Nominations: Best Art Direction-Set Decoration; Australian Film Institute Best Foreign Film; British Academy of Film and Television Arts Awards (BAFTA) Anthony Asquith Award for Film Music, Best Production Design, Best Screenplay - Adapted, David Lean Award for Direction.
Featured Actors: Leonardo DiCaprio as Romeo, Claire Danes as Juliet, Harold Perrineau as Mercutio, Paul Sorvino as Fulgencio Capulet, Pete Postlethwaite as Father Laurence and Miriam Margolyes as the Nurse.
Director: Baz Luhrmann.
QUICK DISCUSSION QUESTION: Romeo and Juliet made their separate decisions to commit suicide relying on certain factual assumptions. What were they? Did these assumptions turn out to be true? What does this tell us about suicide?
Suggested Response: Look at Romeo's situation. There was Juliet, dead in his arms. How could anyone be surer of any fact? It was right there in front of him. But he was wrong. People who commit suicide are most often very upset. In that situation, the person is not operating at their best and their judgment and observations are not to be trusted with life and death decisions.
Look at Juliet's situation. Romeo was dead. She was right about that. But she was a young girl with her entire life in front of her. She had things to do that she cared about, such as making sure that the reconciliation of the Montagues and Capulets was permanent, revering the memory of Romeo, and living her own life. Surely Romeo, in his love for her, would have wanted her to have a long and happy life, even if he would not be around to live it with her. In her pain and despair, she threw all of that away.
European-based civilization has had an evolving attitude about how a spouse should be chosen. In Antiquity and the Middle Ages, among the upper classes where issues of property and power were important, children were their parents' chattel. They married the person their parents selected. Later, children could veto a parents' choice. Juliet's father, Capulet, is ambivalent on this issue. At first he tells Paris, Juliet's suitor:
But woo her, gentle Paris, get her heart,Later, Capulet reverts to the old style, demanding that Juliet marry Paris, on pain of disinheritance.
In later centuries, when children were able to choose their spouse they were still required to obtain the consent of their parents, usually the father, for a marriage. This lasted longer for girls than for boys. The necessity of a father's consent to a marriage figures in many works of art. See Fiddler on the Roof. The final step is the current situation in the United States and Europe in which children simply inform their parents of their choice of a husband or wife. See Guess Who's Coming to Dinner. For more on the West's rejection of arranged marriages in favor of love-matches, see the Helpful Background Section in the Learning Guide to "Pride and Prejudice".
Often quoted phrases from this play:
Juliet: It is an honour that I dream not of.Text and line numbers from The Complete Works of Shakespeare Hardin Craig, editor, Scott, Foresman and Company, Glenview, Ill. 1961.
The Zeffirelli production of "Romeo and Juliet" has been criticized for emphasizing the sentimentality and pathos of the story at the expense of tragedy. The hero and heroine do not ripen in understanding and their deaths are conceived too simply. There is less insight and defiant anger in this production than can be found in the text. Do Juliet and Romeo see how corrupt and flawed their world is? Do they ever understand that love so intense as theirs is self-destructive and cannot last? Do they really come to terms with life and with death? All of these questions can be better answered than they are in this production. This is not to say that this film is not an excellent introduction to the play. Rather it is a beginning. To plumb the depth of this tragedy both children and adults will benefit from seeing several different productions of "Romeo and Juliet," each with a different emphasis.
BUILDING VOCABULARY: apothecary, chambermaid, maid (an unmarried woman), star-crossed, princox, tyrannous, wither, choler.
For English Language Arts classes, distribute TWM's Film Study Worksheet. Teachers can modify the worksheet to fit the needs of each class. Ask students to fill out the worksheet as they watch the film or at the film's end.
Are you concerned that time will be wasted if you are absent from class? Worry no more . . . Check out TeachWithMovies' Set-Up-the-Sub.
Click here for TWM's lesson plans to introduce cinematic and theatrical technique.
Reminder to Teachers: Obtain all required permissions from your school administration before showing any film.
Teachers who want parental permission to show this movie can use TWM's Movie Permission Slip.
Give us your feedback! Was the Guide helpful? If so, which sections were most helpful? Do you have any suggestions for improvement? Email us!
1. See Discussion Questions for Use With any Film that is a Work of Fiction.
2. Romeo and Juliet both have a tragic flaw. What is it? Suggested Response: The love too strongly and they act rashly. Their love blinds them to the other possibilities of life. Romeo, finding Juliet dead, need not have renounced his life. He could have lived to cherish her memory and bring peace between the Capulets and the Montagues. He could have devoted his life to helping others or become a monk. The same is true of Juliet, when she awoke to find Romeo dying or dead. Instead, they act quickly and do not consider anything but their love.
3. What does this play tell us about people? Another way to put this question is, "What was Shakespeare trying to tell us in this play about the way that people act?" Suggested Response: Shakespeare, as usual, is trying to tell us many things. Here are five of them. One is that young people in love have a tendency to lose their perspective. Neither Romeo nor Juliet should have killed themselves. Finding their spouse/lover dead was a tragedy but they compounded it by their suicides. Another thing that Shakespeare was trying to say focuses on the Montagues and Capulets. In their hatred of each other they lost sight of what was important to them and lost their beloved children. A third issue relates to the dangers of revenge. This is more fully developed in other questions. Fourth, he tells us that suicide is not a good solution to our problems. Fifth, he tells us that deception is dangerous and can lead to tragedy. Each of these themes will be explored more fully in questions set out below.
4. Compare the deceptions in this play, and the results of the deceptions, with the deceptions and their results in Much Ado About Nothing. What is Shakespeare trying to tell us about deception? Suggested Response: In this play the deception is the direct cause of the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. In "Much Ado About Nothing" there are several deceptions, some for ill and some for good. It is a comedy. After much trouble caused by the deceptions intended to cause problems, the deceptions for good win out. In both plays the message about deception is the same, i.e., it is very risky and can cause great harm.
5. There is one character in the play who serves as a contrast with Juliet's character. Who is it and in what way does she contrast with Juliet? Suggested Response: The contrasting character is the nurse with her practical approach to love. Remember how she advised Juliet to forget her then-husband Romeo and marry Paris? This highlights Juliet's romantic view of love fixed on one person for whom she will sacrifice all. Juliet's love, like Romeo's, is innocent, spiritual, and intense. The love suggested by the nurse is none of those.
6. There are two characters in the play who contrast with and highlight elements of Romeo's character. Who are they and in what way do they highlight elements of Romeo's character? Suggested Response: The two characters are Tybalt and Mercutio. Tybalt cannot renounce violence even though Romeo tries to placate him and avoid a fight. In this, Tybalt is a foil for Romeo, not learning something and not changing in the way the major character learns and changes. As for Mercutio, his view of love is practical and coarse. Romeo's love, like that of Juliet, is romantic, innocent, spiritual, and intense. It is fixed on one person for whom he will sacrifice all.
7. Watch West Side Story and compare the stories told by the two films. Suggested Response: The similarities include all of the major themes except for the theme of suicide which is not present in "West Side Story". The basic structure of the plot (except for the suicides) and the cast of characters are similar. The differences include: the location: Verona vs. New York; the time: the Middle Ages vs. the 1950s; the conflict: families fighting for something that was never clear vs. gangs of young people fighting for turf; the ending: double suicides vs. Tony is killed by a rival gang member and Maria survives; role of the church: an important role vs. no role; the means of injury: swords, knives, and poison vs. guns and knives. There are probably more differences.
Select questions that are appropriate for your students.
Become a TWM Fan on
A foil is a type of character whose behavior and values contrast with and set off or highlight aspects of another character, usually the protagonist. Often, the foil cannot change in the way that the protagonist changes in the story.
Social-Emotional Learning Discussion Questions:
1. After Romeo has killed Tybalt, Romeo cries out: "I am fortune's fool." What does Shakespeare intend to convey with these words? Suggested Response: Shakespeare is telling us that by giving in to raw instincts for revenge, Romeo has lost his ability to influence events. He is at the mercy of fortune. He dances to the tune of the fates.
2. What were the causes of the death of these lovers? Suggested Response: There are a number of good responses. They include: the hatred that surrounded them; bad luck; poor choices by Romeo in killing Tybalt; poor choices by the lovers in committing suicide.
3. In the Zeffirelli version: Notice the choreography of the fight between Romeo and Tybalt. Tybalt is getting the best of Romeo but when Tybalt goes in for the kill, he leaves himself open for a moment. Romeo recovers just enough to take advantage of that opening and Tybalt is slain. In Baz Luhrmann's "Romeo + Juliet," Romeo offers no resistance to Tybalt at the beach despite the fact that Tybalt beats him mercilessly. But when Tybalt leaves, Romeo follows him and suddenly attacks. Now it is Tybalt who is at disadvantage and he is killed. Is this a realistic way in which fights can happen? What can we learn from these presentations of "Romeo and Juliet" about the risks of fighting? Suggested Response: Both fights are very realistic and show how risky fighting can be. In the Zeffirelli version, Tybalt has Romeo beaten but in the next second Tybalt is killed. In the Luhrmann version, Romeo is so badly beaten that Tybalt leaves, triumphant, only to be pursued by Romeo and killed. What we can learn from this is that fighting is very, very risky. You don't know how it will turn out.
See Discussion Question #2 in the Discussion Questions section.
4. Have you ever felt a love so strong that it consumed all of your other relationships and all of your other interests? Is a love like this healthy? What are its risks and what can people who are swept up in intense relationships do to balance their feelings and lives? Suggested Response: A love as strong as Romeo and Juliet's is not healthy. Life is a multifaceted experience and when we focus on one aspect to the exclusion of all others, we risk tragedy. Moreover, this intense an infatuation usually does not last, because it cannot last. To provide a balance of these feelings people should focus, as well, on their other loving relationships with friends and family.
5. If Romeo or Juliet had close relationships with their parents or other members of their family, would they have been so quick to commit suicide? Suggested Response: The strength of the infatuation of Romeo and Juliet was probably a function of the poverty of the emotional resources of their families. People with strong relationships with family and friends will have a defense against this type of love.
See the Quick Discussion Question.
6. What does the act of suicide say to your relatives and friends? Suggested Response: It says that they are not important enough for you to keep on living. It tells them that you do not love them enough to keep living.
7. Romeo killed Tybalt to avenge the death of Mercutio. Like one character in Hamlet, Romeo took revenge for the killing of a loved one without thinking through the consequences. Who was the character and what were the results of the acts of revenge in each case? Suggested Response: The character was Laertes. (Hamlet, when he stabbed the figure behind the curtain in his mother's bedroom, is another possibility.) In each instance, the act of revenge was unthinking and brought tragedy and death to the person who committed it. Hamlet's act in killing Claudius at the end of the play was not of this nature. See response to Question #9.
8. State the law of unintended consequences and give three reasons why it applies with particular force to acts of revenge. Suggested Response: The law of unintended consequences holds that whether or not what you do has the effect you intend, it will have consequences that you don't expect and therefore consequences that you don't intend. Some unintended consequences can be very unpleasant. Three reasons that the law of unintended consequences applies with particular force to acts of revenge are: (1) In any person's life, acts of revenge are infrequent. Experience is an excellent teacher. If we have little experience with an action, our anticipation of the consequences will be less accurate than if we have taken the action frequently in the past. (2) Revenge usually affects a number of people, either directly or indirectly. Everyone is different and when other people are affected by our actions, there is an increased risk that we won't accurately predict how they'll react. (3) Revenge is often taken in a rage or a fit of passion. Our actions are often not well considered when we are in such a state. Therefore, the risk that we'll fail to anticipate some of the consequences is increased.
9. Compare the role of revenge in this play, with the part it played in Hamlet. What is Shakespeare trying to tell us about the revenge in both of these plays? Suggested Response: Shakespeare is trying to tell us that revenge leads to results we do not think of at the time and which are often tragic. Romeo, Laertes and Hamlet (when he stabs the figure behind the curtain in his mother's bedroom) are committing reflexive unthinking acts of revenge. By the end of his play, Hamlet kills the King, not only for revenge but for the larger purpose of ridding the state of a cancer. Claudius has demonstrated that he will infect anyone who comes near him and that he cares for no one except himself. For a more complete discussion of this interpretation, see Learning Guide to "Hamlet"
Moral-Ethical Emphasis Discussion Questions (Character Counts)
Discussion Questions Relating to Ethical Issues will facilitate the use of this film to teach ethical principles and critical viewing. Additional questions are set out below.
1. Describe the moral messages of the play. Another way to put this question is, "What was Shakespeare trying to tell us in this play about the way that people should or should not act?" Suggested Response: There were many things Shakespeare was trying to tell us. Here are a few. One was that when the authority figures in a society (in this case the leaders of the Montague and Capulet families) embrace hatred, they put at risk things that they love and cherish. They also give a license to their young followers to commit acts of violence and aggression. Another message is that the intense and all-consuming love that Romeo and Juliet feel for each other leads to excesses, in this case to suicide. A third major moral message of the play is the evil and unexpected consequences of revenge.
(Treat others with respect; follow the Golden Rule; Be tolerant of differences; Use good manners, not bad language; Be considerate of the feelings of others; Don't threaten, hit or hurt anyone; Deal peacefully with anger, insults and disagreements)
2. How would Romeo's life (and Juliet's) have changed if, instead of killing Tybalt, Romeo had dealt peacefully with his anger and he had reported the killing of Mercutio to the Prince? Suggested Response: There is no one correct answer because the question requires a prediction of the future. One good answer is that Tybalt would have been arrested and as a wedding present, the newlyweds could have asked that he be pardoned. This would have helped to resolve the bad feelings of the families.
3. Did the fact that Tybalt had killed Mercutio provide any justification or excuse for Romeo when he killed Tybalt? Suggested Response: No. Romeo took the law into his own hands. The Duke had promised to deal harshly with any breaches of the peace and Romeo could have relied upon him to punish Tybalt.
4. What effect, if any, does the fact that Tybalt started the fight in which Mercutio was slain have on your evaluation of the ethical positions of Romeo and Tybalt? Suggested Response: It helps, but not much, because Romeo was seeking revenge when he slew Tybalt.
(Be kind; Be compassionate and show you care; Express gratitude; Forgive others; Help people in need)
5. Had the Montagues and the Capulets forgiven each other, what would have happened to Romeo and Juliet? Justify your answer. Suggested Response: The lovers would not have died and there would have been no tragedy.
(Do your share to make your school and community better; Cooperate; Stay informed; vote; Be a good neighbor; Obey laws and rules; Respect authority; Protect the environment)
6. How would Romeo's life (and Juliet's) have changed if instead of brawling, the Montagues and the Capulets had obeyed the instructions of their Prince and kept the peace? Suggested Response: Romeo and Juliet would have lived and there would have been no tragedy.
Teachwithmovies.com is a Character Counts "Six Pillars Partner" and uses The Six Pillars of Character to organize ethical principles.
Character Counts and the Six Pillars of Character are marks of the CHARACTER COUNTS! Coalition, a project of the Josephson Institute of Ethics.
Bridges to Reading: For Teachers: Assign parts to several people in the class and read various scenes. Suggested scenes to read are: Act One, Scene V; Act Two, Scene IV; Act Three, Scene I; and Act Three, Scene II. There are annotated editions of Shakespeare's plays with explanations of the antique phrases set out in the margins or on a page facing the text. You may want to obtain a copy of one of these books from the library before reading scenes from the play.
Parents: Read scenes from the play as a family. You can compete to see who reads various parts best or just enjoy the beautiful language. After you have read several scenes, see the movie again. If your family has a literary bent, this would be especially fun at family gatherings. All of the aunts and uncles, grandmothers and grandfathers can participate.
Links to the Internet:
Assignments, Projects and Activities:
MOVIES ON RELATED TOPICS: West Side Story is a version of the Romeo and Juliet story played out against gang warfare in New York in the 1950's and without suicide as a factor. See response to Discussion Question #7. See also the other films of Shakespearian plays listed in the Drama section of the Subject Matter Index.
Bibliography: In addition to websites which may be linked in the Guide and selected film reviews listed on the Movie Review Query Engine, the following resources were consulted in the preparation of this Learning Guide:
Last updated July 20, 2011.
Spread the GOOD NEWS about